Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2012

Health Insurance Mandate/Penalty is Just Another Tax


I can’t resist pointing out that I reached the same conclusion as Chief Justice Roberts and the majority more than two years ago.  The penalty you have to pay for not having health insurance is not coercion: it’s just a tax, and not different from dozens of other mandates in the tax law. Not being a lawyer, I had no idea how the court would rule, but as an economist, the question is really a no brainer.  We do this stuff all the time.  (The following is from CNNMoney. I wrote it before I was blogging regularly for Forbes.)
Critics argue that the new law’s requirement to purchase insurance or pay a fine is a radical departure and unconstitutional.
In fact, this is nothing new. Our tax returns are full of implicit mandates with huge penalties — in the form of lost credits and deductions — for noncompliance. The government wants us to donate to charity, own a home, save for retirement, adopt a child, buy a hybrid car … If we don’t, we pay more tax (a penalty).
There is a semantic difference between the health insurance mandate and these other tax nudges in that the government doesn’t require you to donate to charity or own a home. But the government doesn’t really require you to get health insurance either. You are free to ignore the “mandate” and pay the tax.
And some of the other mandates are much more onerous. If I chose to rent rather than own, I’d pay about $7,000 more in taxes — more than three times the maximum penalty for going uninsured.
…
The requirement to file a tax return is itself a pretty serious mandate, involving hefty penalties and sometimes imprisonment for those who opt out. The point is that the new health insurance mandate is different only in form, not in substance, from the plethora of existing mandates.
The new insurance mandate assesses an excise tax of up to $2,085 per family in 2016 (smaller penalties in 2014 and 2015) for those who do not have “minimum essential” health insurance coverage. Low-income families, Native Americans, undocumented immigrants and some religious groups are exempt.
As I noted in the earlier commentary, a lot of the existing mandates are dubious as a matter of policy, but the health insurance mandate is not.  There’s no plausible way in a private health insurance system to get near universal coverage without a mandate. Absent a mandate, people would just wait until they got sick to buy health insurance, but that would send premiums through the roof.  That obviously doesn’t work.
The future of the Affordable Care Act is far from certain. The next presidential election will now be as much about health care as the economy and that is as it should be. There is a constitutional remedy for government policies that people don’t want: an election.
I hope the president does a much better job than he has so far in explaining why people should support the law (and his reelection). We’ll find out if he did on November 6.
Follow me on twitter.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Obama is a Lightweight in the Intimidation Game

Republican leaders are outraged that the president is trying to "intimidate" the Supreme Court into supporting his health reform law. It is an election year so hyperbole and feigned outrage are to be expected, but if the GOP wants to find politicians engaging in intimidation, they should look in the mirror.

First, let't look at what the president said, as reported by Fox News:

"I'm confident that the Supreme Court will not take what would be an unprecedented, extraordinary step of overturning a law that was passed by a strong majority of a democratically elected Congress," Obama said. "And I'd just remind conservative commentators that for years what we've heard is the biggest problem on the bench was judicial activism or a lack of judicial restraint, that an unelected group of people would somehow overturn a duly constituted and passed law. Well, this is a good example. And I'm pretty confident that this court will recognize that and not take that step."
But exactly how does the president intimidate the Supreme Court? The president can't do anything to the Supreme Court if it displeases him. Supreme Court Justices have lifetime tenure. Do the critics worry that Justice Kennedy or Roberts would change their votes because they didn't want to disagree with the president? Whether or not the president opined on the subject, could the Justices have any doubt about what the president's views are? The president's solicitor general did have three days to make the president's case directly to the Supreme Court, rather than to reporters in the Rose Garden.

But the talk of intimidation did remind me of a much more egregious case back in September, when the Republican leadership sent a letter warning Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and the Fed governors not to engage in any more quantitative easing.

It is our understanding that the Board Members of the Federal Reserve will meet later this week to consider additional monetary stimulus proposals. We write to express our reservations about any such measures. Respectfully, we submit that the board should resist further extraordinary intervention in the U.S. economy, particularly without a clear articulation of the goals of such a policy, direction for success, ample data proving a case for economic action and quantifiable benefits to the American people.
Ezra Klein of the Washington Post summarized the message as "Nice central bank you got here. Shame if something should happen to it." This is real intimidation. Congress can legislate limits on the Fed's autonomy and hold up confirmation of appointees to the Board of Governors. Fed governors do not have lifetime tenure. They must routinely testify before Congressional committees. The Republican leaders' warning had real teeth.

And there's also one more meaningful difference between the two episodes. Messrs. McConnell, Boehner, Kyl, and Cantor are professional pols with no training in economics or monetary policy. They have no business lecturing Ben Bernanke, a distinguished scholar with a fabulous reputation in the profession, on economics.  Barack Obama taught constitutional law at University of Chicago, one of the best law schools in the country.


Follow me on twitter.